“SEO is evolving with AI. Focus on high-quality, helpful content, follow E-E-A-T, optimise for AI search and diversify your traffic sources.”
12 findings below, each with the exact words and a link to the thread.
01Rankings improved. Clicks fell anyway.
Against the consensus
The most repeated 2026 complaint is not lost rankings but lost clicks at the same or better rank. One site's non-brand CTR fell from 1.9% to 0.6% while its average position improved from 9.6 to 5. Another lost about 90% of clicks overnight while still in the top 5. Practitioners now price positions differently: position 1 behaves like old position 4. A commenter cites an Ahrefs study of 300k keywords showing a 58% lower click rate for the top result when an AI Overview appears. Not everyone agrees: for a page at position 8.2 with 0.3% CTR, one reply says the position does more damage than the AIO.
“If I take out rought brand queries, it went from 1.9 to 0.6%. but the impressions are up here. The avg position has improved too (9.6 to 5).”r/SEO ↑2 · 2026-08-31
“Position 1 is on par with position 4. Position 2-4 is on par with basically position 5-10 and everything else is effectively page 2”r/SEO ↑3 · 2026-09-11
“ahrefs looked at 300k keywords and the top organic result had a 58% lower click rate once an overview showed up”r/SEO ↑1 · 2026-11-03
Stop paying for rank-tracking reports as proof of progress, and stop treating rank drops as the problem to fix. Split Search Console queries into those with and without an AI Overview: if only the AIO set lost clicks, no audit or content refresh will bring them back, and that budget should move.
02Traffic down, leads flat: the lost clicks weren't buyers
Against the consensus
Several agencies and in-house SEOs report sessions falling while leads hold or rise. Clients are down 1-5% (up to 10%) in traffic with leads ticking up, and one site's loss sat in about 15 informational queries while commercial queries were fine. A YMYL site lost about 35% overnight on informational queries while transactional pages held. Reporting sessions costs agencies accounts: one lost a client to a competitor over AIO traffic loss alone.
“traffic is down 1 to 5%, rankings are normal/solid, and leads are ticking up”r/SEO ↑9 · 2026-10-29
“the drop was concentrated in about 15 informational queries; the commercial ones were fine”r/SEO ↑1 · 2026-08-28
“move the headline number from sessions to leads. If leads held while sessions fell, the client has lost nothing”r/SEO ↑1 · 2026-10-06
Re-baseline the KPI before cutting SEO: report leads and revenue from organic, not sessions. Treat informational clicks as gone and put new content money into pricing, comparison and local pages. For an agency, this one reporting change is the difference between a renewal and a cancellation.
03AI referrals: tiny volume, best leads, fragile
Hard number
First-hand numbers are small but consistently high-intent: 37 ChatGPT sessions in 90 days with 2m38s engagement vs 1m for organic; 5-10 ChatGPT quote requests a week, about 15% of one B2B client's leads; 1 ideal-customer lead per 6 AI sessions, one worth a $40K opportunity. Another team says AI chat now returns only 15-20% of the organic traffic it lost. And the channel can vanish: a subscription site's ChatGPT referrals, its best converting channel, fell from about 15 a day to 0-4 on Oct 9, 2026, while OpenAI's bots kept crawling. A store hit by a Google update saw its ChatGPT traffic drop with it.
“37 sessions from ChatGPT in 90 days, with 2m38s average engagement vs 1m for organic”r/juststart ↑1 · 2026-08-05
“In my experience in B2B SaaS, out of 6 AI sessions, we got 1 ICP lead. One AI referral turned into a $40K opportunity for the brand.”r/SEO ↑1 · 2026-10-02
“ChatGPT referrals were very stable through September, around 15 sessions a day, and they were our best converting channel.”r/SEO ↑14 · 2026-11-03
Track ChatGPT as its own channel (referrer + landing page + signups) and value it per lead, not per visit. Do not build a plan that replaces lost Google volume with AI volume: the data says it replaces maybe a fifth of it, and one product change at OpenAI can take it to zero.
04Bing is the cheap side door into ChatGPT
What worked
Practitioners repeatedly link ChatGPT visibility to Bing's index; one cites Ahrefs: only about 12% of URLs ChatGPT cites rank in Google's top 10. A tourism site that lost 73% of Google sessions overnight saw Bing and ChatGPT traffic stay flat, and one agency's ecommerce client gets 30% of revenue from Bing. The point is disputed: other commenters say ChatGPT moved to Google results, and Bing citations convert poorly (3M Copilot citations sent about 300 visits).
“Ahrefs found only about 12% of the URLs ChatGPT cites also rank in Google's top 10 for the same query”r/SEO ↑1 · 2026-10-02
“Over the same period, Bing organic traffic and visits from ChatGPT have remained completely stable.”r/SEO ↑30 · 2026-07-30
“One of my major ecom clients gets 30% of their revenue from Bing.”r/bigseo ↑30 · 2024-12-16
Bing Webmaster Tools, IndexNow and a Bing Places listing cost hours, not a retainer, and they diversify away from a single Google algorithm. It is the cheapest AI-visibility bet in this dataset; measure it with Bing's AI performance report before buying any GEO tool.
05Programmatic SEO: 60% deindexed by month four
Pain point
We found at least a dozen programmatic or templated-page crashes reported first-hand in 2025-2026, e.g. 800 B2B SaaS pages, 60% deindexed by month 4; 400k URLs falling from about 5,000 to 200 clicks a day; 4,500 food pages pushed in one day, then zero impressions for a month; 16k templated pages crawled, impressions -84% the next day; 3,000 auto-generated pages on an 80-song site, -90%; 27k pages launched at once, almost nothing indexed. Survivors had data that exists nowhere else, links from hand-written pages, or launched in batches of about 100.
“roughly 60% of pages got pulled from the index by month 4”r/bigseo ↑35 · 2026-05-01
“like i had city+service pages for 200 cities and google decided most of them were answering the same query. so instead of ranking 200 pages it ranked zero.”r/bigseo ↑2 · 2026-02-20
“then around july 17 it did not decline, it flatlined. zero impressions, zero clicks, every day for over a month”r/SEO ↑44 · 2026-08-20
Kill any plan that ships thousands of city/product-swap pages at once. If the pages have no unique data, the expected value is negative: they can drag down the whole domain, including old pages. Ship 100, measure indexation for 90 days, then scale.
06Median reported drop: 70%. Recoveries rare.
Hard number
Across 39 loss reports with a computable percentage in 32 threads, the median loss is 70% and 33 of 39 are 50% or worse. In 23 of 39 no cause is named at all. Hit content sites were sold for a fraction of their value ($28k to $5k, $50k to $10k), and a seller who exited a craft site at $102k says buyers are bearish on content sites. Commenters who audited HCU-hit sites say they stayed hit; the reported comebacks came after 12+ months, often with no changes. The pattern continues: a gaming news site lost 83% of pageviews in three days in the November 2026 core update.
“roughly 94k pageviews on Nov 10, 66k on Nov 11, 23k on Nov 12 and 16k on Nov 13.”r/SEO ↑22 · 2026-11-16
“I sold mine, it’s initial worth was )28k, but I sold it for $5k.. lol, back to the drawing boardz”r/juststart ↑3 · 2024-01-06
“My traffic tanked from over 400,000 page views a month from Google down to about nothing (less than 4000 views p/m).”r/Blogging ↑33 · 2025-03-10
For an informational site already down 70%+, a $9-15k "recovery audit" (the price quoted in one thread) is the worst use of money in this dataset. Decide early between selling, pivoting the traffic source (video, social, email), or rebuilding around pages AI cannot answer.
07Survivors: local pages, tools, comparison content
What worked
What still grows, by first-hand report: local service pages (a window cleaner's 28 area pages got the phone ringing), Google Business Profile plus real reviews (page 4 to page 1), tools and calculators (one owner's blog tanked while their tool site hit an all-time high), and comparison or "alternatives" pages where buyers choose. Video also took back rankings lost to HCU. Even tools are not safe forever: one commenter points to Google's plan for AI Overviews that build tools.
“And the single biggest thing that moved the needle was just having a proper page for each area.”r/juststart ↑333 · 2026-04-09
“If you have any local component to your business, the ROI on local SEO efforts is insane compared to competing nationally.”r/bigseo ↑53 · 2025-10-29
“One of my website (blog) tanked :( after the update and one (tool website) reached all time high.”r/bigseo ↑2 · 2025-07-21
Move content budget from "what is X" guides to one page per service area, comparison and pricing pages, and one interactive tool. For a local business, a GBP and reviews programme is the highest-ROI line item mentioned in these threads.
08GEO talk up 40x; measured results lag
Shift in progress
In the full r/bigseo feed, posts mentioning GEO/AEO/AI visibility went from 0.2% of posts (3 of 1226) in H1 2024 to 8.4% (96 of 1143) in H2 2026. Results have not kept pace: tracking tools are called synthetic, the same prompt returns different brands each run, and llms.txt has no believers. Of 36 comments mentioning llms.txt, 13 call it useless or report zero effect, against 7 positive. One owner logged zero bot visits to it in a month.
“am I the only one who thinks the number of GEO experts grew faster than the number of people with actual GEO results?”r/bigseo ↑33 · 2026-07-22
“The same prompt does not return the same brands twice, so twenty prompts checked once a week gives you twenty coin flips rather than twenty measurements.”r/bigseo ↑1 · 2026-09-01
“I kept track of the server logs to see how many times any bot has crawled it. I gave up after a month and 0 crawls.”r/bigseo ↑10 · 2025-11-12
Before paying for a GEO retainer or tracking tool, run 10-20 fixed buyer prompts several times per engine and log the cited sources yourself: practitioners say that is what tools sell. Skip llms.txt projects. Most of what moves AI citations is ordinary SEO plus third-party mentions.
09Agency prices, and why clients cancel
Hard number
Quoted retainers: $1,500-5,000 a month for decent ecommerce SEO; $1,000 minimum for local; $600 a month buys about a day's work (2 page optimisations, 2 posts, 2 links). One insider says agencies charge 2k and pay the worker 300. Cancellations follow one pattern: traffic KPIs met, no pipeline. A Series B SaaS (about $4M ARR) fired its content agency after 8 months, 47 posts and zero demos, and another agency gets renewal doubts even with organic traffic up 40%.
“High volume keywords, lots of traffic, zero buying intent.”r/bigseo ↑59 · 2026-04-21
“on the renewal call it's "we're not really sure what we got this month" while their organic traffic is up 40%”r/SEO ↑25 · 2026-06-12
“most agencies charge $1,500 to $5,000 / month for anything decent”r/bigseo ↑8 · 2026-08-11
Write the contract around leads or revenue from non-brand organic, keep admin ownership of GSC and GA4, and never accept DR or traffic as the KPI (one owner's "thousands of percent" growth turned out to look like bot traffic). For agencies: price on pipeline or lose the renewal call.
10Link prices: $25 to $2,000 per link
Hard number
The quoted price ladder: agency-bought links at $25-150; the same links via a service $250-350, rising over two years; typical seller rates $50-200, up to $500, and about $2k for NYT editorial access; an $800 "DA92" link; $50k of reactive digital PR for about 100 links. Paying page owners for an AI-cited mention runs $50-180, and one roundup with 0 monthly visitors asked $6,000 to list a tool. At the other end, one outreach campaign got 8 links at average DR 38 for $20 total from 350 pitches. A single earned NYT link was valued by a legal client at about $50k.
“this 3rd-party agency is only bringing in paid links ($25, $50, sometimes $150/link)”r/bigseo ↑13 · 2026-07-04
“You’d likely pay $250-350 per link from a service acquiring those exact same links.”r/bigseo ↑1 · 2026-07-05
“most asks land $50 to $180 in my own outreach”r/SEO ↑2 · 2026-10-28
Audit any retainer that consists mainly of $25-150 links: thread consensus is that they come from sites with no traffic. Put the same money into one linkable asset (original data, a newsworthy local event) that earns press: it is the only link type with reported long-term payoff.
11Reddit took the SERP; Reddit services are snake oil
Shift in progress
An informal study of about 10k queries (Google Custom Search API) found Reddit in 12.07% of top results, ahead of YouTube at 6.68%. Expert publishers report being replaced by Forbes, Quora and Reddit, and users append "reddit" to queries to skip SEO sites. But practitioners say selling "Reddit marketing" for revenue is snake oil: the real uses are reputation management and getting cited by LLMs, which favour Reddit threads.
“the HCUs over that past year have effectively wiped us off the map and replaced us with Forbes, Hudson Reporter, Chicago Reader, Quora, Reddit”r/juststart ↑13 · 2024-01-06
“searching a question, then re-searching question + reddit, to get around all of the SEO'd bullshit sites”r/juststart ↑2 · 2024-08-28
“Anyone promising amazing revenue growth through Reddit posts is selling snake oil.”r/bigseo ↑3 · 2025-08-07
Answer buyer questions on Reddit under a real company account to earn LLM citations and SERP presence for brand terms. Do not pay an agency for Reddit link drops: practitioners say links get downvoted in valuable subs and the traffic is mostly zero-click.
12How owners describe it, in their words
Their words
In their own words, owners describe Google answering with their work and not sending people, and they distrust anyone who says nothing changed. These lines work as ad and landing-page copy for anyone selling to site owners in 2026, and as interview prompts for discovery calls.
“Google just summarizes my exact conclusions in the snapshot without anyone ever clicking through.”r/bigseo ↑14 · 2026-10-23
“If you are a content-only site where the information is the product, then you are eaten alive”r/SEO ↑6 · 2026-08-30
“The only people who say that nothing has changed and that their traffic is better than ever are those trying to sell you something.”r/Blogging ↑8 · 2026-11-06
Use the owners' framing ("Google answers with my content, nobody clicks") in offers and sales calls instead of jargon. It matches the pain they feel and sets up a leads-not-traffic pitch.
Payback
One decision pays for the report: dropping a $1,500-5,000/month retainer that reports traffic instead of leads, cancelling a $9-15k HCU "recovery audit", or not launching a few thousand programmatic pages that could sink the domain. Each saves more than €449 in the first month.
Where the data runs out
Self-reported, unaudited numbers from people who chose to post. Loss stories are over-represented, because people post when traffic crashes. Half the threads are from r/bigseo, which leans towards practitioners and agencies. Percentages are from owners' own GSC/GA4 screens, and some cited studies (Ahrefs, Reddit share) are retold, not checked. Arctic Shift search was rate-limited during collection, so r/affiliatemarketing (2 threads) is thin and r/TechSEO, r/digital_marketing and r/Entrepreneur are not covered. Data ends 2026-11-17, in the middle of the November 2026 core update rollout.